Skip to content

Sims 4 vs Sims 3: Which One Is Better?

Written by
Sean Hollister
Sean Hollister Comparisons editor, GameCuki Published
Inside GameCuki How We Review
361Guides
1K+Products Compared
41Free Games

GameCuki is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Sims 4 vs Sims 3 is one of the longest-running arguments in life sims, and it still gets new answers every year. One game is free, polished and easy to run. The other is a bigger, looser sandbox with a world that never stops. The real question is whether you want a smooth, modern experience or the freedom of an open neighborhood.

Best for Most New Players
Sims 4 vs Sims 3 comparison, The Sims 4 store capsule art

The Sims 4

Bottom LineThe easier pick for anyone starting out, with a free base game, better looks and a lot of recent updates, as long as you can live with loading screens.

View on Steam
Best for Open-World Fans
The Sims 3 store capsule art

The Sims 3

Bottom LineThe pick if you want a seamless neighborhood and Sims who keep living without you, but it looks dated and takes more effort to run well.

View on Steam
Table of Contents
  1. Release and Price: One Is Free, the Other Is Not
  2. Graphics and Performance: Sims 4 Looks Better and Runs Easier
  3. Open World: Sims 3 Has the Real Neighborhood
  4. Gameplay and Story Progression: Sims 3 Keeps Living
  5. Build Mode and Create-a-Sim: Different Strengths
  6. Content and Mods: Sims 3 Starts Bigger, Sims 4 Caught Up
  7. Sims 4 vs Sims 3: Full Specs
  8. And the Winner Is…

Release and Price: One Is Free, the Other Is Not

The Sims 3 launched in 2009, and The Sims 4 followed on September 2, 2014. Since October 18, 2022, the base game of The Sims 4 has been free on all platforms, which changed the whole debate. The Sims 3 is still a paid game, and most of its content lives in separate expansion and stuff packs.

The Sims 4 has also grown a lot. It currently lists 21 expansion packs and 12 game packs, plus smaller stuff packs and kits. The Sims 3 has 11 expansion packs and 9 stuff packs. Both games get expensive once you start adding packs, so the free base game gives The Sims 4 a much cheaper way in.

The Sims 4 – Official Free Base Game Launch Trailer

Graphics and Performance: Sims 4 Looks Better and Runs Easier

The Sims 4 has the cleaner, brighter look. Textures are smoother, characters have more detail, and the cartoon style has aged better than the more realistic approach of The Sims 3. It also tends to run more consistently, with fewer crashes and less lag, especially if you have been burned by an overloaded Sims 3 install.

The Sims 3 is the easier game to run on very old hardware. Its minimum requirements are a 1.5 GB RAM Vista machine, while The Sims 4 needs a 64-bit Windows 10 PC with 4 GB of RAM. Heavy expansion and mod setups can still make The Sims 3 unstable on any computer, though.

Quick pick: go with The Sims 4 if you want a game that looks good and behaves itself out of the box.

Open World: Sims 3 Has the Real Neighborhood

This is where The Sims 3 earns its loyal fans. Its neighborhoods are seamless, so your Sims walk or drive between lots with no loading screens on PC. The base game’s town, Sunset Valley, feels like a living place, and cars are part of that.

The Sims 4 splits the world into separate lots, and traveling between them means a loading screen. Cars are gone entirely. It makes the game feel smaller and more broken up, and it is the most common complaint players raise about it.

The Sims 3 Official Trailer

Gameplay and Story Progression: Sims 3 Keeps Living

In The Sims 3, story progression is built in, so Sims you are not playing keep working, dating, having kids and moving through life on their own. That makes the town feel alive and gives you surprises when you switch households.

The Sims 4 does not include this in the base game, so only the household you are playing really changes. Players who want it can add it through mods. What The Sims 4 does offer is a stronger emotion system and better multitasking, so your Sims react to their mood and can do more than one thing at a time.

Build Mode and Create-a-Sim: Different Strengths

Both games have deep customization, but they lean different ways. The Sims 4 has the faster, friendlier Build mode, with tools to move and duplicate whole rooms, and its Create-a-Sim is widely praised for how quickly you can shape a character. The Sims 4 also has the Gallery, which lets you share Sims and builds and download other players’ creations.

The Sims 3 has Create-a-Style, which lets you recolor and retexture clothing and objects with your own colors, materials and patterns. If you love designing exact looks rather than picking presets, that tool is still a big draw.

Content and Mods: Sims 3 Starts Bigger, Sims 4 Caught Up

At launch, The Sims 4 was criticized for missing features from earlier games, including swimming pools, toddlers and open worlds. Free updates have since brought back several of them, including pools and toddlers, but the open world never returned. The Sims 3 base game still feels fuller, with cars, pools and toddlers from the start.

Custom content and mods work on both, but they are not equal in effort. Installing mods in The Sims 4 is mostly a matter of dropping files into a folder, while The Sims 3 relies on a slower, launcher-based setup.

Sims 4 vs Sims 3: Full Specs

FeatureThe Sims 4The Sims 3
DeveloperMaxis / Electronic ArtsMaxis Redwood Shores / Electronic Arts
ReleasedSept. 2, 2014June 2, 2009
Base game priceFree since Oct. 2022 WinsPaid
PlatformsWindows, Mac, PS4, Xbox OneWindows, Mac, PS3, Xbox 360, Wii, DS, 3DS, mobile
Minimum PC OS64-bit Windows 10Windows XP SP2 or Vista SP1 Wins
Minimum RAM (PC)4 GB1 GB (XP) or 1.5 GB (Vista) Wins
Open worldNo, loading between lotsYes, seamless on PC Wins
Story progressionNot in base gameBuilt in Wins
CarsNoYes Wins
GraphicsSmoother, brighter WinsDated, more realistic
Build and Create-a-SimRoom tools, Gallery WinsCreate-a-Style
ModsFolder-based WinsLauncher-based
Expansion packs21 Wins11
Metacritic (PC)7086 Wins

And the Winner Is…

WinnerThe Sims 4

The Sims 3 deserves its reputation. Its seamless open world, built-in story progression and cars give it a sense of place that The Sims 4 has never matched, and its higher Metacritic score reflects that. Still, The Sims 4 is the one to start with for most people. It is free, it looks better, it runs more smoothly, it is simpler to mod, and it keeps getting updates. In the Sims 4 vs Sims 3 debate, pick The Sims 3 if an open neighborhood and Sims with their own lives matter more to you than polish or a modern look. Everyone else, especially anyone new to the series, should install The Sims 4 first. If you enjoy slow, cozy life sims beyond the Sims, our Coral Island vs Stardew Valley comparison is a good next read.

Get The Sims 4 on Steam
About the Author
Sean Hollister

Sean Hollister

Comparisons editor, GameCuki

Bio

I'm Sean, and I write the comparisons on GameCuki. I cover anything gamers weigh up before buying: consoles and handhelds, PC components and gaming laptops, monitors, controllers, headsets and accessories, plus subscriptions and services like Game Pass and PlayStation Plus. I put both options on the same checklist, using official specs, professional reviews and owner feedback, and I only mention what owners say when at least two of them report the same thing. Every comparison ends with one clear verdict and the type of player each option suits. I don't accept free products or payment from brands, and what I write comes from research, not my own use of the products. You can read my full process on our How We Review page.

Areas of Focus

Controller Match-UpsHeadset Match-UpsConsole vs. ConsoleSpecs & Latency