Skip to content

Hollow Knight vs Hollow Knight Silksong: Which Should You Play First?

Written by
Sean Hollister
Sean Hollister Comparisons editor, GameCuki Published
Inside GameCuki How We Review
361Guides
1K+Products Compared
41Free Games

GameCuki is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Same studio, same hand-drawn dread, two very different pace settings. Hollow Knight vs Hollow Knight Silksong is a real question if you have time for only one of them right now, because the sequel is faster, harder and bigger, while the original is slower and easier to settle into. Here is how they split on combat, builds, difficulty, world and reception.

Best for a Gentler First Descent
Hollow Knight cover art for the Hollow Knight vs Hollow Knight Silksong comparison

Hollow Knight

Bottom LinePick it if you want a complete, atmospheric Metroidvania with a slower pace and optional challenges, and you plan to play both in release order.

View on Steam
Best for Veterans Who Want Speed
Hollow Knight: Silksong cover art

Hollow Knight: Silksong

Bottom LinePick it if you already know the genre and want faster combat, more mobility and a deeper loadout, and you can live with a steeper early game.

View on Steam
Table of Contents
  1. Combat and Movement: Slow Nail vs Fast Needle
  2. Builds and Progression: Charms vs Crests and Tools
  3. Difficulty: Silksong Puts More Challenge on the Main Path
  4. World and Story: Hallownest vs Pharloom
  5. Platforms and Requirements: Both Run on Modest PCs
  6. Reception: Both Are Modern Indie Landmarks
  7. Hollow Knight vs Hollow Knight Silksong: Full Specs
  8. Hollow Knight vs Hollow Knight Silksong FAQ
  9. And the Winner Is…

Combat and Movement: Slow Nail vs Fast Needle

The biggest gap is speed. In Hollow Knight you play the Knight, a silent vessel armed with a nail. Swings are deliberate, so you win by reading a pattern and committing to a strike at the right moment.

Silksong puts Hornet in the lead. She attacks faster, moves with more agility and picks up mobility tools such as the Clawline, Drifter’s Cloak, Cling Grip for wall climbing and Silk Soar. Silk, gained by hitting enemies, powers both her healing and her Silk Skills, so fights push you to stay aggressive instead of backing away.

Hollow Knight: Silksong – Release Trailer

Quick pick: go with Silksong if twitchy, vertical fights sound fun, and Hollow Knight if you would rather read a boss and answer it calmly.

Builds and Progression: Charms vs Crests and Tools

Hollow Knight builds around charms. Each one costs notches, and your notch count is the budget you fit them into. Currency is Geo, and dying drops it all and leaves a Shade you must defeat to get it back.

Silksong replaces that system with Crests and Tools. A Crest changes your attack speed and range and has its own mechanic, so it works a bit like a class. Tools come in color-coded types: blue and yellow are passive or supportive, while red ones are offensive and have limited charges that Shell Shards refill at Benches. The cap on tools changes with the Crest you equip. That gives Silksong more loadout variety, while Hollow Knight stays easier to understand at a glance.

Difficulty: Silksong Puts More Challenge on the Main Path

Silksong is the harder game. Bosses hit faster and the early hours are less forgiving. Enemies deal two points of damage, which is two-fifths of Hornet’s starting health, though she heals faster and more strongly than the Knight. Long runbacks, scarce currency and awkward diagonal pogo jumps are the usual sore spots.

Hollow Knight keeps most of its worst bosses off the critical path. You can walk past a lot of optional hardship, and its free Godmaster content pack adds five Pantheons for players who want the brutal stuff on purpose.

Quick pick: if you have bounced off tough Metroidvanias before, Hollow Knight is the safer door in.

World and Story: Hallownest vs Pharloom

Hollow Knight takes place in Hallownest, a fallen insect kingdom reached from the small town of Dirtmouth. It is quiet, ruined and told mostly through environments, with three Dreamers to defeat and three main endings.

Silksong moves to Pharloom, a vertical kingdom that is brighter in tone but just as haunted. Hornet speaks, so the story can lean on her more directly than the wordless Knight. The sequel began life as downloadable content for the first game, after a Playable Hornet stretch goal was met in the 2014 Kickstarter, and it grew into a full standalone game.

Hollow Knight Trailer

Platforms and Requirements: Both Run on Modest PCs

Hollow Knight arrived on Windows on February 24, 2017, followed by Switch, PS4 and Xbox One, and reached PS5, Xbox Series X/S and Switch 2 on February 5, 2026. Silksong launched on September 4, 2025 across PC, Mac, Linux, Switch, Switch 2, PS4, PS5, Xbox One and Xbox Series X/S.

On Windows the minimum specs listed on Steam are almost identical: an Intel Core i3-3240 or AMD FX-4300, 4 GB of RAM and a GeForce GTX 560 Ti or Radeon HD 7750. Hollow Knight asks for 9 GB of storage and Silksong for 8 GB. If your laptop is older, our guide to the best Steam games for low-end laptops has more options.

Reception: Both Are Modern Indie Landmarks

Hollow Knight passed 15 million copies sold by August 2025 and holds a 96% positive rating on Steam. Silksong passed 5 million players in its first three days, sold over 7 million copies by December 2025 and won Best Action/Adventure Game at The Game Awards 2025. Its Steam rating is lower, mostly because of the difficulty complaints above, but its Metacritic score on the Steam page is higher.

If you like tougher, pattern-driven action, see how the genre’s biggest names stack up in our Lies of P vs Sekiro comparison.

Hollow Knight vs Hollow Knight Silksong: Full Specs

FeatureHollow KnightHollow Knight: Silksong
DeveloperTeam CherryTeam Cherry
Release dateFebruary 24, 2017 (Windows)September 4, 2025
ProtagonistThe KnightHornet
SettingHallownestPharloom
Build systemCharms and notchesCrests and Tools Wins
CurrencyGeoRosaries and Shell Shards
PaceDeliberateFast and acrobatic
DifficultyChallenge mostly optional WinsHarder on the main path
Steam user reviews (Oct. 20, 2026)Overwhelmingly Positive, 96% of 565,835 WinsVery Positive, 89% of 426,066
Metacritic (Steam page)8790 Wins
Copies soldOver 15 million (Aug. 2025)Over 7 million (Dec. 2025)
Windows minimum storage9 GB8 GB Wins

Hollow Knight vs Hollow Knight Silksong FAQ

Is Silksong better than Hollow Knight?

It depends on what you value. Silksong has the deeper loadouts, faster combat and higher Metacritic score on Steam, while Hollow Knight has the stronger user rating and a gentler difficulty curve. Neither one is strictly better.

Do I need to play Hollow Knight before Silksong?

No, Silksong is a standalone game. Playing the original first does make Hornet’s move into the lead feel more meaningful.

Is Silksong harder than Hollow Knight?

Yes. Faster bosses, a less forgiving early game and more challenge on the main path make it the tougher of the two.

Which should I play first?

Most players should start with Hollow Knight, then move on to Silksong once the genre feels comfortable.

And the Winner Is…

WinnerHollow Knight

Silksong does plenty better. Its combat is quicker, Hornet is more mobile, the Crest and Tool system gives you more ways to build a playstyle and its Metacritic score on Steam is higher. It is also the more demanding game, and its early hours can be rough. Hollow Knight wins this round because it is the easier game to love from the first hour, it is a complete story with a long list of free content packs and its Steam rating is higher. If you are weighing Hollow Knight vs Hollow Knight Silksong for a first purchase, start with the original. Pick Silksong first only if you already finish hard Metroidvanias and want the sharpest, fastest version of the formula.

View Hollow Knight on Steam
About the Author
Sean Hollister

Sean Hollister

Comparisons editor, GameCuki

Bio

I'm Sean, and I write the comparisons on GameCuki. I cover anything gamers weigh up before buying: consoles and handhelds, PC components and gaming laptops, monitors, controllers, headsets and accessories, plus subscriptions and services like Game Pass and PlayStation Plus. I put both options on the same checklist, using official specs, professional reviews and owner feedback, and I only mention what owners say when at least two of them report the same thing. Every comparison ends with one clear verdict and the type of player each option suits. I don't accept free products or payment from brands, and what I write comes from research, not my own use of the products. You can read my full process on our How We Review page.

Areas of Focus

Controller Match-UpsHeadset Match-UpsConsole vs. ConsoleSpecs & Latency